Welcoming Adults Back to Singing

Make The First Visit Easier

by Liuba Doga

We welcome a new guest blogger to this forum and thank her for timely contribution. Her article supports my persistent soapbox on adult amateurs eliminating the fear of returning to recreational music-making. (See my rant “Stamp Out the PHOBIA of Amateur Music-Making” here.) In Southwestern PA, we are attempting to promote community music groups with an ensemble directory and a concert calendar posted here in the arts section of my local Community Foundation of Upper St. Clair website. Are you participating regularly in a band, chamber group, chorus, jazz combo, theater production, or orchestra? WHY NOT? What are you waiting for? PKF

An adult thinking about returning to singing may have a practical question before a musical one: “What will happen when I walk through the door?” They may remember a school choir, have sung privately for years, or be starting again after a long break. None of those histories tells a teacher exactly what the person wants now.

For a choir leader or voice teacher, the welcome begins before the first note. Clear information, a considerate introduction and an achievable way to join in can make the first visit less mysterious. The aim is to give the singer enough information and choice to take a useful next step.

Explain the first visit before it happens

Read your invitation as someone who has never attended. Does it explain whether there is an audition, whether music-reading experience is expected, and what newcomers will be asked to do? “All welcome” leaves those questions unanswered.

Tell people how long the meeting lasts, what to bring and whom to ask for on arrival. If the session is online, explain how to join and whether each person will sing individually. Describe recording arrangements in advance and ask permission before recording anyone.

Where there is an audition, explain its purpose and format. If a group cannot accommodate a returning beginner, say so kindly and suggest an appropriate alternative when you know one. A clear description helps adults choose a setting that fits their current needs.

Ask what they want to return to

Begin with the person’s musical interests. They might want to sing at home, join a community choir, take lessons or participate more comfortably in congregational singing. Ask, “What would you like singing to be part of in your life now?”

Follow with an invitation to share relevant experience: “Is there anything you would like me to know before we begin?” Let the singer decide how much to explain. They do not need to account for every year away from music or disclose a difficult experience to deserve a thoughtful welcome.

Avoid treating previous participation as a complete assessment. A former chorister may want help following a score again; someone who has never joined a group may know a large repertoire by ear. Listen to the person in front of you.

Give newcomers a clear way to participate

Choose an opening activity with a clear purpose and explain it before asking someone to sing. In an individual lesson, that might mean offering a familiar song or a short phrase as a starting point, then choosing a suitable key together. There is no need to make the first activity a demonstration of everything the voice can do.

In a group, explain which part people should follow, where to find the starting point and what the leader’s cues mean. Where your format allows it, offer newcomers the option to listen to a passage before joining the repeat. Make that option explicit so they do not have to guess whether listening is permitted.

A small practical detail can carry much of the welcome: the right score, a visible page number, or someone who can quietly point out the next entry. Ask before pairing a newcomer with another singer, and make sure that person is willing to help.

Preserve adult choice

Returning to music does not mean returning to childhood. Explain why you are asking for an activity and make room for questions. Avoid surprise solos or public introductions that require a newcomer to describe their musical history.

Be specific about what participation involves without making promises about confidence, range or speed of progress. “Today we can explore this song and discuss what you would like to work on” is a clear invitation. It leaves room to discover what the singer needs.

If someone describes themselves as “rusty,” you do not need to argue with the word or offer an instant verdict on their ability. You can acknowledge the time away and move toward a concrete task: “Let’s begin with a song you know and take it from there.”

Make the second visit easy to understand

Before the singer leaves, explain what would happen next. For a choir, confirm the next rehearsal, any joining arrangements and how to obtain the music. For lessons, discuss a realistic next step that fits the singer’s interests and available time.

Invite an honest response: “Was anything unclear today?” or “Is there something you would like explained before another session?” These questions give the newcomer a way to raise practical concerns without having to evaluate their own singing on the spot.

An invitation to return should leave room for choice. Someone may want time to think, a different group or another way into music. A considerate first encounter still matters, even when it does not lead to immediate enrolment.

Review the welcome as carefully as the music

Afterward, look at the experience from the newcomer’s position. Which instructions depended on knowledge a regular member would already have? Was there a clear person to ask for help? Did the singer leave knowing how to return?

Welcoming adults back to singing is practical teaching work. A clear invitation, respectful choices and an understandable next step give people a place to begin. The music can grow from there.

About the author

Liuba Doga is the founder of Singing Attitude, providing online vocal coaching for adults worldwide. Her approach brings together Technique, Attitude and Expression, with attention to each singer’s musical interests and goals.

© 2026 Liuba Doga and Paul K. Fox

Seniors: A Warm-up Welcome

Ken Gargaro’s Open House Introducing Encore Players & Encore Singers

It’s never too late to take the stage.

They say timing is everything… and one definition of a coincidence is “an accidental alignment of time, place, or situation that feels meaningful…”

I was invited to represent PMEA Council for Teacher Training, Recruitment, and Retention along with my PMEA District 1 colleagues Lucas Beaver and Cynthia Mancini at the Duquesne University Music Career Connect on October 27. At the seminar, we “bumped into” Dr. Ken Gargaro, founder of Pittsburgh Musical Theater (now retired). I’ve seen and yelled BRAVO at so many of his outstanding shows. Another retired music educator, Vito DiSalvo, wrote this excellent bio about his Western PA performing arts career: https://www.vitodisalvo.com/dr-ken-gargaro-bio.html

Gargaro’s current project is to form “a joyful theater and singing company for seasoned adults 55 and older.” To launch his Encore Players and Encore Singers, he is sponsoring an OPEN HOUSE information session on Wednesday, November 18 at the Vincentian Theater (8150 McKnight Road, McCandless).

Here is his flier. Please help spread the word throughout the Southwestern, PA choral, theater, and education community.

A man after my own heart, Gargaro is “in sync” with my philosophy and “soapbox” (I admit it – I am a nag) about seniors (especially retired musicians, singers, dancers, and actors) to intentionally fulfill meaningfully productive years of creative self-expression “living the dream” in retirement. See this blog-post about seniors participating in recreational music: https://paulfox.blog/2026/06/06/stamp-out-the-phobia-of-amateur-music-making/.

Next week (November 15), we are posting the article “Welcoming Adults Back to Singing” by guest blogger Liuba Doga from Singing Attitude. She’s “spot on” reinforcing this perspective and provides new insights to calm the fears of seniors returning to membership in a choral ensemble and “What will happen when I walk through the door?”

PKF

© 2026 Paul K. Fox

Sing Your Heart Out… Now and in Retirement

pmeaReprinted from the Spring 2016 issue of PMEA News, the state journal of the Pennsylvania Music Educators Association.

 

choir-1258225_1280

Isn’t the Internet a wonderful place to validate something you have always known? After only a brief Google search, the research seems overwhelming! Here are my top five reasons all of us should participate in a choir… throughout our adult lives!

  1. Singing promotes a healthy immune system.

lungs-39980_1280If you’ve ever been in a choir, you’ve probably been told that the proper way to sing is from your belly.

The idea is to use your diaphragm – the large muscle that separates your chest and abdominal cavities – to push air out through your vocal cords.

Using your diaphragm to sing is a good way to promote a healthy lymphatic system, which in turn promotes a healthy immune system.

Dr. Ben Kim at http://drbenkim.com/articles-singing-for-health.htm.

  1. Singing soothes the savage beast… and makes you feel better!

relax-1183452_1920As the popularity of group singing grows, science has been hard at work trying to explain why it has such a calming yet energizing effect on people. What researchers are beginning to discover is that singing is like an infusion of the perfect tranquilizer, the kind that both soothes your nerves and elevates your spirits.

Group singing is cheaper than therapy, healthier than drinking, and certainly more fun than working out.  It is the one thing in life where feeling better is pretty much guaranteed.

Stacy Horn at http://ideas.time.com/2013/08/16/singing-changes-your-brain/

  1. Don’t you want to live longer? Singing is “heart healthy!”

aorta-151145_1280Regular exercising of the vocal cords can even prolong life, according to research done by leading vocal coach and singer Helen Astrid, from The Helen Astrid Singing Academy in London. “It’s a great way to keep in shape because you are exercising your lungs and heart.”

Singing… helps you live longer according to the findings of a joint Harvard and Yale study, which showed that choral singing increased the life expectancy of the population of New Haven, Connecticut. The report concluded that this was because singing promoted both a healthy heart and an enhanced mental state.

Heart Research UK at http://heartresearch.org.uk/fundraising/singing-good-you

  1. Think “karaoke!” Singing builds “connections” with each other and social confidence.

singer-84874_1920Colette Hiller, director of Sing The Nation, is convinced that singing builds social confidence by helping individuals connect to each other, and to their environment. “Think of a football stadium with everyone singing,” she says. “There’s an excitement, you feel part of it, singing bonds people and always has done. There’s a ‘goosebumpy’ feeling of connection.”

Chorus America, an organization of singing groups in the United States of America, conducted a survey a few years ago, and found that more people in the U.S. and Canada take part in choral singing more than in any other performing art, since they feel that singing in a chorus builds social confidence. Nikki Slade, who runs The Priory, a chanting and voice-work class, believes that the benefits of singing are linked to the primacy and power of the human voice – and that it is our basic instinct to use it. “People are naturally free and expressive,” she says, “but it’s something that has been lost on a day-to-day basis.” Singing can help restore that lost connection.

http://www.shankarmahadevanacademy.com/community/articles/view/6/

  1. Singing reduces stress and pain, and benefits “senior citizens” especially well.

stress-1277561_1920Studies have linked singing with a lower heart rate, decreased blood pressure, and reduced stress, according to Patricia Preston-Roberts, a board-certified music therapist in New York City. She uses song to help patients who suffer from a variety of psychological and physiological conditions.

“Some people who have been traumatized often want to leave the physical body, and using the voice helps ground them to their bodies,” Preston-Roberts says. “Singing also seems to block a lot of the neural pathways that pain travels through.”

Singing, particularly in a chorus, seems to benefit the elderly particularly well. As part of a three-year study examining how singing affects the health of those 55 and older, a Senior Singers Chorale was formed by the Levine School of Music in Washington, D.C.

choir-305535_1280The seniors involved in the chorale (as well as seniors involved in two separate arts groups involving writing and painting) showed significant health improvements compared to those in the control groups. Specifically, the arts groups reported an average of:

  • 30 fewer doctor visits
  • Fewer eyesight problems
  • Less incidence of depression
  • Less need for medication
  • Fewer falls and other injuries

The seniors themselves also noticed health improvements, said Jeanne Kelly, director of the Levine School of Music, Arlington Campus, who led the choral group. The seniors reported:

  • Feeling better both in daily life and while singing
  • Their everyday voice quality was better
  • The tone of their speaking voice did not seem to age as much
  • Easier breathing
  • Better posture

http://www.sixwise.com/newsletters/06/06/07/how_singing_improves_your_health_even_if_other_people_shouldnt_hear_you_singing.htm

female-1299085_1280Okay, besides that crack about “elderly” in that last article (we’re not “old,” yet!), the evidence seems conclusive! For our general health, feelings of well-being, improved social connections, and “just having fun,” we should all be motivated TODAY to go out and find a community choir and start singing regularly in a group. Enough said?

Similar to the “nearly comprehensive” instrumental ensemble listing published by PMEA retired members in the Fall 2015 issue of PMEA News, check out the recently released directory of Pennsylvania community choruses.  Sorted by ensemble’s name and also by location, these files of PA community bands/orchestras and choirs will be updated (new groups added) from time to time, and new revisions will be posted online under “focus areas” and “retired members” of the PMEA website: http://www.pmea.net/retired-members/. (If you have any corrections or additions, please send them to paulkfox.usc@gmail.com.)

choir-783666_1920For both the instrumental and choral groups, we are most thankful to the contributions of our “dream team” of PMEA researchers and editors (as of April 13, 2016): Jan Burkett, Craig Cannon, Jo Cauffman, Deborah Confredo, Susan Dieffenbach, Timothy Ellison, Paul Fox, Joshua Gibson, Rosemary Haber, Estelle Hartranft, Betty Hintenlang, Ada Jean Hoffman, Thomas Kittinger, Chuck Neidhardt, Sarah Riggenbach, Ron Rometo, Joanne Rutkowski, Marie Weber, Lee Wesner, and Terri Winger-Wittreich. We are especially grateful to the efforts of Director of Member Engagement Joshua Gibson who located the counties and e-mail addresses in the choir directory.

Now, what are you waiting for? Go out and… sing!

PKF

© 2016 Paul K. Fox

eric-whitacre-522604_1920